As I mentioned after my Thanksgiving day wishes, there has a been a lot of buzz about the Manhattan Declaration. To me, this is something which is far too important to ignore.
For those who may not know, let me start by explaining what the Manhattan Declaration is. I will not be posting the Declaration itself here on my blog, but please feel free to go to www.manhattandeclartion.org to check it out for yourself, and see if you think that my characterization is accurate. It is certainly not my intention to, in any way, or at any time, mislead anyone, or misrepresent what this is all about.
The Manhattan Declaration, according the declaration itself, is "A Call Of Christian Conscience." It was originally drafted on October 20th of 2009, and released to the public on November 20th of 2009.
The document addresses three main issues, abortion, same-sex marriage, and religious liberty. It purports to be a document which unites differing Christian groups around these very important issues. It lays out a case for the pro-life position, and against Abortion. It lays out a case in favor of preserving marriage as a sacred institution, and why we should strive against allowing same-sex marriages to be recognized. It also outlines the dangers faced by religious groups in the present age, where there is much animosity directed at anyone who dares to so much as disapprove of nearly anything.
To the extent that it does these things I would support it as a statement of position, and as a place for people of conscience to rally, and say, OK, we have differences, but we all agree that these things are important, so let's stand together on them. But that is not all that the document says. And it going farther, it leaves a lot to be desired.
Clearly, I am pro-life. If you wish to call me anti-abortion, that's fine, I'm not going to fight you on it, I am anti-abortion, because I'm pro-life. As far as it goes, I think that the declaration does a pretty good job of laying out some good arguments and points for a pro-life position, however, for something that supposes to be a Christian document, it spends far too much time expounding secular arguments instead, and virtually no time on Biblical arguments, save a couple of verses of Scripture which are never explained or defended in any way. Also, I do believe that marriage is only possible, in a very real sense, between one man and one woman, and again, the declaration does a very good job of laying out a secular case for traditional marriage, but again, is staggeringly weak when it comes to a Biblical basis, which is especially important on this issue, because, if the Bible didn't speak to this issue I personally wouldn't really care about it at all. I also understand the importance of religious liberty, but again, it is defended and explained entirely with secular arguments. So, while I can affirm the positions taken by the declaration, I think that they could have done a better job laying them out and defending them, and the fact that they didn't defend them from the Bible is a serious problem for me.
All that being said, let me get on to the main problem that I have with the Manhattan Declaration.
The document makes a big deal about Christians, and where they stand on important issues. But what is meant by "Christian"? Well, to quote from the declaration; "We, as Orthodox, Catholic, and Evangelical Christians..." This should be another problem for Bible believing Christians. The fact that this document lumps Evangelical Christians in with Catholics, as well as, so-called, Orthodox, sounds huge warning bells in my mind, as the beliefs of these groups are wildly different. This brings me back to how the Manhattan Declaration came to my attention. Initially I had heard Chuck Colson talk about some, which is not surprising since he is one of the people who wrote it, but I hadn't had time to check it out. Then a friend asked me if I had signed it yet, and I could only respond that, up to that point, I hadn't had time to check it out yet. So, when I had time, I went to the website, www.manhattandeclaration.org, and checked it out.
The first that I saw when I got to the website was the very brief summary that is there, and I decided to look and see who had signed the declaration. While there are some very well known Christian leaders on the list, you can't help but notice more than a few Roman Catholic Archbishops on the list. For any Bible believing Christian, this has to give you pause when considering something like this. So I knew I was going to have to look very closely at the declaration before I could make up my mind, so I pulled up the full declaration and read the entire thing.
If you should read the declaration you will find that only scant lip service is given to the Gospel, and even then it is not defined or explained in any way shape or form, yet we know for sure that a Roman Catholic Archbishop would mean something very different by Gospel than I do. Given that this document was written with the idea in mind that it was for the approval of Catholics and Christians, it seems clear that the true Gospel of Jesus Christ is not what's in view even the one time that it is mentioned. And no, in a pure sense, Catholics are not Christians. At it's best Catholicism is an apostate form of Christianity, but not true Biblical Christianity. That is not to say that no Catholics are truly redeemed, but given what is taught in most Catholic Churches and circles, I would venture to say that they are a rare breed.
Having established that the purposes of this document are not to further the Gospel, what then could they be? Well, it must have to do with propagating morality, but if that's all they are concerned with, why mention Christianity at all? Simply to have a grounding for the morality they are seeking? Perhaps, but if so, that does not do justice to the purpose of Christianity. The purpose of Christianity is to share the Gospel with the entire world. That's it, that's the core, it's why the Church exists. Our mission to spread the Gospel, to preach the Gospel, is the reason the Church is in the world, it's the reason God doesn't rapture (sorry, it's the best word I can think of for this) us out of the world the instant we come to faith in Him. And that is the true Gospel of Jesus Christ, that we are sinners in a fallen world, in danger of eternal judgment from a righteous and Holy and Just God, and can be redeemed out of this world and saved from that damnation only by grace and through faith in the person and work of Jesus Christ, which is something that could not be affirmed by many of the signers and endorsers of the declaration.
Now, from the Catholic perspective, there is a certain logic to this declaration. Being that Catholicism, as it is practiced, and as it is taught in most local Parishes and such, is a very legalistic religion, believing in a works based righteousness (often you will hear that the works must be coupled with faith, but even that is a gross bastardization of the Gospel) and that being good at least gets you closer to Heaven, no matter why you are good, it would make sense to force people, through political action or whatever, to be better, and thus put them closer to God, even if you have to drag them, kicking and screaming, to it. But this is not something that is compatible with Biblical Christianity. If a person rejects the Gospel of Jesus Christ, that is the true Gospel, then they are damned and destined for Hell, and just how good or bad they are is of little consequence to them.
So, if I were to sum up the Manhattan Declaration, I would have to put it something like this: "We, under the guise of Christianity, demand adherence to our moral standards. We stand up, shake our fist at the culture and say, you will submit to us, we will see to it. We couldn't care less if you go to hell for all eternity, we will have our moralistic domain here and now! We don't care if you believe, only that you submit!"
But wait, there's something familiar about that sentiment, it's Islam! That's right, Islam doesn't require an affirmation of faith, only submission to it's laws and teachings. That's what's going on with the Manhattan Declaration, it's declaring that we don't care what you believe, only that people submit to the moral standards that it puts forth. This is all too common amongst people who wish to claim Christianity. It is what Dr. Michael Horton calls Moralistic, Therapeutic Deism. That is, we try to be moral, and it makes us feel better, and oh yeah, as an afterthought, there is a god, but that doesn't really affect us.
For me to affirm the Manhattan Declaration would be to say, if you are homosexual, you can go to hell, as long as you go without a marriage license. If you are woman, you can go to hell, as long as you go without having had an abortion. And I will fight for religious liberty, and disregard laws that I think conflict with that, while also refusing to submit to the consequences of such action. That is something that I absolutely cannot affirm. No matter who you are, or what your sin, I want you to learn about Jesus, repent of your sins, and be redeemed. If you are going to hell anyway, it doesn't matter what sin you committed, it will separate you from God.
So do I support the Manhattan Declaration? Will I be signing it? No. Unreservedly, and emphatically, NO!
There is more to be said, and I know that some will raise objections to what I've written, but I'll have to deal with those as they arise, because this long enough already.
Hebrews 4:12
For the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart.
Showing posts with label Ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ethics. Show all posts
Monday, November 30, 2009
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
What You Need To Know About Health Care
With all of the lies and hype in the media, there are some things that we need to make sure that people understand about what we will end up with if we allow a Government takeover of health care, and that they are lying in order to try to ram it through.
First of all, the number of uninsured that we hear about every day on various news outlets. Probably the number most often thrown around is 47 million, although you do also hear 50 million, 46 million, 46.5 million, and so on. You must understand somethings about this number to see that it is a complete lie. First of all, they use the 47 million figure to try to make you think that there are 47 million American Citizens that are chronically uninsured and simply have no hope of ever being covered. The truth is that some of this number, around 9 to 12 million, is illegal aliens, and not citizens at all. Another large chunk of this number comes from people who were without health insurance for less than four months while they were out of work, but had no serious long term lapse. Another large chunk is young people who can easily afford health insurance, but choose not to buy it, because they simply feel that they don't need it. So when the numbers are analyzed and understood, the fact is that there are somewhere from 10 to 15 million chronically uninsured American Citizens. Still an issue, but clearly something that doesn't require a Government takeover of health care to solve.
Another point is that in the United States being uninsured is not the same thing as not having access to health care. Because of laws in this nation, anyone who shows up at an Emergency Room must be evaluated and treated until they are stable, without regard to their ability to pay. By saying this I'm not trying to make a claim that the issue is solved, simply that we do not have millions of people dying in the streets because they don't have health care. Are there still some horror stories? Sure, but they do not arise from the fact that people are uninsured, and therefore, overhauling the insurance industry will not affect them in the slightest.
Furthermore, it must be understood that the claims made by the proponents of a Government takeover of health care are simply not possible. They claim that they will cover more people (47 million by their own claims) and expand services, while at the same time reducing costs. That is just utterly ridiculous on it's face. The only way that they can reduce costs is by rationing the care. That is to say that for each year there are X number of dollars available for each area of care, and once those dollars are gone, they are gone, and we don't do any more of that until next year. That means that they have to assign priority to different people to see who they will spend some of those precious few dollars on, and if you are old, or have some condition that renders you unable to hold down a job, and thereby pay taxes, you will not be the priority, you will simply be left to die, so that you won't burden the system for the "productive members of society." I'm not kidding, one of the main advisers on health care to the Obama Administration has stated in the past the Health Care dollars should not be spent on people with dementia or some other debilitating disease, and that he doesn't think that age discrimination is wrong because, now listen to this reasoning, everyone who is 65 was once 25.
If this plan gets pushed through, it will not be doctors and patients making choices about health care, it will be faceless, nameless, bureaucrats in cubicles, thousands of miles away, to whom you are nothing more than a number and a formula. These people who are pushing this plan accuse the Republicans of being the "party of No," claiming that we simply say no, and don't offer alternative plans. Of course this is another big lie, we have some plans that would actually work to make Health Care better, but even if we didn't, there would be nothing wrong with standing up and saying "NO" to making it worse.
First of all, the number of uninsured that we hear about every day on various news outlets. Probably the number most often thrown around is 47 million, although you do also hear 50 million, 46 million, 46.5 million, and so on. You must understand somethings about this number to see that it is a complete lie. First of all, they use the 47 million figure to try to make you think that there are 47 million American Citizens that are chronically uninsured and simply have no hope of ever being covered. The truth is that some of this number, around 9 to 12 million, is illegal aliens, and not citizens at all. Another large chunk of this number comes from people who were without health insurance for less than four months while they were out of work, but had no serious long term lapse. Another large chunk is young people who can easily afford health insurance, but choose not to buy it, because they simply feel that they don't need it. So when the numbers are analyzed and understood, the fact is that there are somewhere from 10 to 15 million chronically uninsured American Citizens. Still an issue, but clearly something that doesn't require a Government takeover of health care to solve.
Another point is that in the United States being uninsured is not the same thing as not having access to health care. Because of laws in this nation, anyone who shows up at an Emergency Room must be evaluated and treated until they are stable, without regard to their ability to pay. By saying this I'm not trying to make a claim that the issue is solved, simply that we do not have millions of people dying in the streets because they don't have health care. Are there still some horror stories? Sure, but they do not arise from the fact that people are uninsured, and therefore, overhauling the insurance industry will not affect them in the slightest.
Furthermore, it must be understood that the claims made by the proponents of a Government takeover of health care are simply not possible. They claim that they will cover more people (47 million by their own claims) and expand services, while at the same time reducing costs. That is just utterly ridiculous on it's face. The only way that they can reduce costs is by rationing the care. That is to say that for each year there are X number of dollars available for each area of care, and once those dollars are gone, they are gone, and we don't do any more of that until next year. That means that they have to assign priority to different people to see who they will spend some of those precious few dollars on, and if you are old, or have some condition that renders you unable to hold down a job, and thereby pay taxes, you will not be the priority, you will simply be left to die, so that you won't burden the system for the "productive members of society." I'm not kidding, one of the main advisers on health care to the Obama Administration has stated in the past the Health Care dollars should not be spent on people with dementia or some other debilitating disease, and that he doesn't think that age discrimination is wrong because, now listen to this reasoning, everyone who is 65 was once 25.
If this plan gets pushed through, it will not be doctors and patients making choices about health care, it will be faceless, nameless, bureaucrats in cubicles, thousands of miles away, to whom you are nothing more than a number and a formula. These people who are pushing this plan accuse the Republicans of being the "party of No," claiming that we simply say no, and don't offer alternative plans. Of course this is another big lie, we have some plans that would actually work to make Health Care better, but even if we didn't, there would be nothing wrong with standing up and saying "NO" to making it worse.
Friday, May 1, 2009
That's The Argument?
The other night at President Barack Obama's most inane press conference to date he was asked a question about Abortion. I was utterly floored by the outright silliness of his answer. Now, as usual, he spoke for several minutes, running out the clock to avoid the possibility that someone might actually ask him a serious question, not that Abortion is not a serious issue, but everyone knows how radically pro-abortion Obama is, so you can't really say asking his position constitutes a serious question. Anyway, the point is, you have to learn to ignore the clutter words and cut to the relevant section of any quote when listening to Obama. So here it is, he said that Pro-Choice is the correct position on the issue of Abortion because, are you ready for this? Because the women don't take the choice lightly!
Seriously, that was his argument in defense of Abortion. Utterly stunning isn't it? So, let's take a look at it, since it is, after all, the defense of a position offered by the President of the United States.
If you've read much of my blog, and if not you always have the option of looking back at the archives, you will see that I have addressed the Abortion issue multiple times, and explained why it is murder, why it is taking the life of an innocent human being, and posted several excellent explanations of the horror of Abortion from the wonderful people from Stand To Reason (linked in the sidebar), but Obama simply dismissed all of that, saying that it's OK because the women don't take the choice lightly, so, therefore, we must conclude from what he said, that there is nothing wrong with it for that reason alone.
Of course, you simply can't apply that kind of "logic" to a single issue, if it's good enough for Abortion, it's good enough for pretty much everything, right? So, what happens if we apply this concept across the board. What you come up with is a system whereby any action is justified as long as the decision to undertake that action is well considered, and of course, not taken lightly, and the action itself cannot be questioned, and is not subject to judgements of right or wrong or ciminality, or anything else. Under a system like this crime could only be punished if the perpetrator took the choice to commit the crime lightly.
Therefore:
Carjacking, OK as long as the criminal doesn't take the choice to carjack lightly.
Murder, OK, as long as the murderer doesn't take the choice to murder lightly.
Armed Robbery, OK, as long as the robber doesn't take the choice to rob lightly.
Rape, OK, as long as the rapist doesn't take the choice to rape lightly.
Genocide, OK, as long as the genocidal maniac doesn't take the choice to exterminate millions of people lightly.
War, OK, as long as the warmonger doesn't take the choice to wage an unjust war lightly.
Adultery, OK, as long as the cheater doesn't take the choice to cheat lightly.
Assault, OK, as long as the attacker doesn't take the choice to attack lightly.
I could go on and on, but I think the point is made.
In short, no matter what a person chooses to do is fine, as long as it is well considered, or not taken lightly. So said our President. Now, regardless if you like Obama or not, or if you are Pro-Life or Pro-Abortion, everyone has to see that this was about the silliest thing that could have been said, and nobody challenged him on it, now isn't that sad?
Seriously, that was his argument in defense of Abortion. Utterly stunning isn't it? So, let's take a look at it, since it is, after all, the defense of a position offered by the President of the United States.
If you've read much of my blog, and if not you always have the option of looking back at the archives, you will see that I have addressed the Abortion issue multiple times, and explained why it is murder, why it is taking the life of an innocent human being, and posted several excellent explanations of the horror of Abortion from the wonderful people from Stand To Reason (linked in the sidebar), but Obama simply dismissed all of that, saying that it's OK because the women don't take the choice lightly, so, therefore, we must conclude from what he said, that there is nothing wrong with it for that reason alone.
Of course, you simply can't apply that kind of "logic" to a single issue, if it's good enough for Abortion, it's good enough for pretty much everything, right? So, what happens if we apply this concept across the board. What you come up with is a system whereby any action is justified as long as the decision to undertake that action is well considered, and of course, not taken lightly, and the action itself cannot be questioned, and is not subject to judgements of right or wrong or ciminality, or anything else. Under a system like this crime could only be punished if the perpetrator took the choice to commit the crime lightly.
Therefore:
Carjacking, OK as long as the criminal doesn't take the choice to carjack lightly.
Murder, OK, as long as the murderer doesn't take the choice to murder lightly.
Armed Robbery, OK, as long as the robber doesn't take the choice to rob lightly.
Rape, OK, as long as the rapist doesn't take the choice to rape lightly.
Genocide, OK, as long as the genocidal maniac doesn't take the choice to exterminate millions of people lightly.
War, OK, as long as the warmonger doesn't take the choice to wage an unjust war lightly.
Adultery, OK, as long as the cheater doesn't take the choice to cheat lightly.
Assault, OK, as long as the attacker doesn't take the choice to attack lightly.
I could go on and on, but I think the point is made.
In short, no matter what a person chooses to do is fine, as long as it is well considered, or not taken lightly. So said our President. Now, regardless if you like Obama or not, or if you are Pro-Life or Pro-Abortion, everyone has to see that this was about the silliest thing that could have been said, and nobody challenged him on it, now isn't that sad?
Labels:
Abortion,
Debate,
Ethics,
Life,
Media Bias,
Opinion,
Philosophy,
Politics
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Showing His True Colors
Many of us have been trying to get the point across for some time now that just because some politicians call themselves Republicans does not meant that they actually ascribe to classic Republican values, or that they are in any way Conservatives. Finally, one of the worst of these GOP fakers has decided to leave the Republican Party and join in with the Democrats, where he's more comfortable anyway.
This is no small change, as it once would have been. Today, the Republican Party is the last line of defense for the American spirit, and the principles that our Nation was founded on. Unfortunately, the Republican party has been doing a lousy job of this in recent years, but there is hope among many of us that we may be able to awake this sense of purpose once again, and fight to get our Country back on the right track.
What we need in the GOP are people with real backbone, who are willing to stand up in the face of the Democrat Majority, and the Media who push all things leftist and despise all things Conservative. We can do without cowards and turncoats like Arlen Specter, who sides with the Democrats on the really important issues anyway. Someone who wants to be loved by the media, and knows that he was likely to lose his seat in a Republican Primary in any event, has now decided to see if he can hold onto his power by switching parties, but I truly hope that the GOP resurgence will see this worthless old jerk finally out of the Senate.
This is no small change, as it once would have been. Today, the Republican Party is the last line of defense for the American spirit, and the principles that our Nation was founded on. Unfortunately, the Republican party has been doing a lousy job of this in recent years, but there is hope among many of us that we may be able to awake this sense of purpose once again, and fight to get our Country back on the right track.
What we need in the GOP are people with real backbone, who are willing to stand up in the face of the Democrat Majority, and the Media who push all things leftist and despise all things Conservative. We can do without cowards and turncoats like Arlen Specter, who sides with the Democrats on the really important issues anyway. Someone who wants to be loved by the media, and knows that he was likely to lose his seat in a Republican Primary in any event, has now decided to see if he can hold onto his power by switching parties, but I truly hope that the GOP resurgence will see this worthless old jerk finally out of the Senate.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Dishonest Indignation
Last night the local news had a report about a gambling operation being raided and shut down by the State in Orlando yesterday. The reporters, the law enforcement officials, the state officials, and pretty much everyone else was indignant about how this place was operating against Florida's anti-gambling laws, and that they were ripping people off, because so many people played and lost money, while so few people won anything at all.
A few things about this story bothered me, though it seemed to all be lost on the news reporters and such. First, they talked about the people who ran the operation as if they were armed robbers, forcibly stealing money from unsuspecting innocent people. While I certainly don't approve of what they were doing, and it could almost certainly be classified as stealing, the so called victims were hardly innocent bystanders. These people went to this establishment looking for some easy money, and thinking that they were the ones that would get lucky and strike it rich, knowing full well that in all likelihood, they would leave with less than they came in with. In fact, it looked like most of the people who went there were regulars. Now, I'm not defending the operation in any way, they were preying on the desperate, but let's face it, they did not take the money at the point of a gun, the people handed it over to them willingly.
The other thing that really bothered me was the utter dishonesty on the part of the reporters and the State officials. They were all claiming, be it implicitly or explicitly, to be outraged and disgusted that such an operation is going on in Florida. They were just indignant that there was a gambling operation designed to take advantage of desperate, low income people, where those people would be nearly certain to lose their money and end up with nothing to show for it, or, at best, win back far less than they would lose over the long haul. But maybe I'm being too harsh, maybe they really are outraged, maybe they've never heard of the Florida Lottery!
That's right, the Lottery, in any state, but today I'm talking about Florida, is based on the same principles as the operation that was shut down by the State yesterday. They prey on desperate and low income people, who stand a very low chance of winning anything, and if they do, most of them lose far more over the course of their lives than they will ever win (let's face it, if the Lottery were a good way to make money, rich people would play it too, and they don't). The state makes huge profits off of the Lottery, supposedly for Education, but don't worry, sticky fingered politicians find ways around that (yes even here in Florida, it's not just a New York problem). And that is the real source of the outrage. You see, the Government officials and the reporters and all of them aren't upset because this is going on in Florida, they are upset because somebody was encroaching on their turf. Like a mob boss who is angry when another mob tries to operate in his territory, he's not angry that there crime there, he's angry because he's not getting his cut. It's the same with the State.
Wait, what? Did he just call the State a bunch of Mafia thugs?!? Yes, I basically did. Now, don't get me wrong, it's not that I want places like this operating all over the place, it's just the horrendous display of dishonesty I saw in this news report. Let's be honest about it, the State doesn't want this going on unless they are getting their cut, and that's the truth.
A few things about this story bothered me, though it seemed to all be lost on the news reporters and such. First, they talked about the people who ran the operation as if they were armed robbers, forcibly stealing money from unsuspecting innocent people. While I certainly don't approve of what they were doing, and it could almost certainly be classified as stealing, the so called victims were hardly innocent bystanders. These people went to this establishment looking for some easy money, and thinking that they were the ones that would get lucky and strike it rich, knowing full well that in all likelihood, they would leave with less than they came in with. In fact, it looked like most of the people who went there were regulars. Now, I'm not defending the operation in any way, they were preying on the desperate, but let's face it, they did not take the money at the point of a gun, the people handed it over to them willingly.
The other thing that really bothered me was the utter dishonesty on the part of the reporters and the State officials. They were all claiming, be it implicitly or explicitly, to be outraged and disgusted that such an operation is going on in Florida. They were just indignant that there was a gambling operation designed to take advantage of desperate, low income people, where those people would be nearly certain to lose their money and end up with nothing to show for it, or, at best, win back far less than they would lose over the long haul. But maybe I'm being too harsh, maybe they really are outraged, maybe they've never heard of the Florida Lottery!
That's right, the Lottery, in any state, but today I'm talking about Florida, is based on the same principles as the operation that was shut down by the State yesterday. They prey on desperate and low income people, who stand a very low chance of winning anything, and if they do, most of them lose far more over the course of their lives than they will ever win (let's face it, if the Lottery were a good way to make money, rich people would play it too, and they don't). The state makes huge profits off of the Lottery, supposedly for Education, but don't worry, sticky fingered politicians find ways around that (yes even here in Florida, it's not just a New York problem). And that is the real source of the outrage. You see, the Government officials and the reporters and all of them aren't upset because this is going on in Florida, they are upset because somebody was encroaching on their turf. Like a mob boss who is angry when another mob tries to operate in his territory, he's not angry that there crime there, he's angry because he's not getting his cut. It's the same with the State.
Wait, what? Did he just call the State a bunch of Mafia thugs?!? Yes, I basically did. Now, don't get me wrong, it's not that I want places like this operating all over the place, it's just the horrendous display of dishonesty I saw in this news report. Let's be honest about it, the State doesn't want this going on unless they are getting their cut, and that's the truth.
Friday, March 27, 2009
Where Are They Now?
It's been a few years since we were introduced to the idea of "Hate Crimes." A new and fairly radical idea of supposed justice, where ones actions in the commission of a crime actually become secondary to their motive. Motive is important when establishing that a person is guilty of a crime, sometimes a jury has trouble believing that a person is guilty if they don't understand why that person might have done it. However, with the introduction of hate crimes laws, we see that a persons motive is influencing far more than the verdict of guilty or not guilty, but the actual sentence received if they are indeed found guilty.
The whole idea is truly absurd. If someone kills another person, they should be punished for that crime, regardless of the motive. Is the person who is killed for their race more valuable than the person who is killed for money? Is the Muslim who is beaten for his religion any more a victim than the Atheist who is beaten at random, for being in the wrong place at the wrong time? Is the crime truly more heinous because the motive in a certain category? Certainly not. But that is what many would have us believe.
First it started with applying the hate crimes laws to who a person is, things such as their race or gender, and what a person believes, things such as religion. Naturally though, they couldn't even leave it at that, they demanded that it be expanded to cover what a person chooses to do, and so they covered homosexuals. This last one to the point that even saying that you believe that Homosexuality is a sin is considered a hate crime in some places. Still, the point is that by their own definition they want to cover what a person does, so why aren't they trying to protect the AIG execs?
It seems to me that these people are being targeted for where they work, which falls under the category of what they do. Aside from the fact that most, if not all, of the people who were being awarded the bonuses had no part in the failure of their parent company, and had genuinely earned the bonuses that they were being paid, the fact of the matter is that they are being threatened with bodily harm, and even death to themselves and their families because they happen to work at a company where people other than themselves did irresponsible things, and squandered the money that these people had worked so hard to make.
However, even if these were the very people responsible, I think that the expanded hate crimes laws should apply. They are being targeted for what they do, so why haul in all of the people who have threatened them, and all of the people (politicians included) who have incited these feelings of hatred, and charge them with hate crimes, after all, why wait for a crime to be committed, if you're going to punish someone for what they think, instead of what they do, then why not head them off at the pass and lock them all up before they have a chance to hurt anyone. You think I'm joking, but just wait, it won't be long before someone proposes just that, but not for thoughts against just anyone, just against the favored groups of their own choosing.
This brings up one more point though, couldn't this be applied to our very criminal justice system? Couldn't someone say, hey, you protected people from being harassed or harmed for what they do, well, I say you're just arresting and prosecuting me because I'm a murderer and you just hate murderers. Absurd? Yes, but it's the logical conclusion of their own absurd ideas.
Hate crimes laws boil down to just one thing, quelling dissent. That is to say, silencing anyone with a differing point of view, not to protect anyone, not to make society more just, but rather to eliminate freedom of speech, and with it all other freedoms we enjoy.
The whole idea is truly absurd. If someone kills another person, they should be punished for that crime, regardless of the motive. Is the person who is killed for their race more valuable than the person who is killed for money? Is the Muslim who is beaten for his religion any more a victim than the Atheist who is beaten at random, for being in the wrong place at the wrong time? Is the crime truly more heinous because the motive in a certain category? Certainly not. But that is what many would have us believe.
First it started with applying the hate crimes laws to who a person is, things such as their race or gender, and what a person believes, things such as religion. Naturally though, they couldn't even leave it at that, they demanded that it be expanded to cover what a person chooses to do, and so they covered homosexuals. This last one to the point that even saying that you believe that Homosexuality is a sin is considered a hate crime in some places. Still, the point is that by their own definition they want to cover what a person does, so why aren't they trying to protect the AIG execs?
It seems to me that these people are being targeted for where they work, which falls under the category of what they do. Aside from the fact that most, if not all, of the people who were being awarded the bonuses had no part in the failure of their parent company, and had genuinely earned the bonuses that they were being paid, the fact of the matter is that they are being threatened with bodily harm, and even death to themselves and their families because they happen to work at a company where people other than themselves did irresponsible things, and squandered the money that these people had worked so hard to make.
However, even if these were the very people responsible, I think that the expanded hate crimes laws should apply. They are being targeted for what they do, so why haul in all of the people who have threatened them, and all of the people (politicians included) who have incited these feelings of hatred, and charge them with hate crimes, after all, why wait for a crime to be committed, if you're going to punish someone for what they think, instead of what they do, then why not head them off at the pass and lock them all up before they have a chance to hurt anyone. You think I'm joking, but just wait, it won't be long before someone proposes just that, but not for thoughts against just anyone, just against the favored groups of their own choosing.
This brings up one more point though, couldn't this be applied to our very criminal justice system? Couldn't someone say, hey, you protected people from being harassed or harmed for what they do, well, I say you're just arresting and prosecuting me because I'm a murderer and you just hate murderers. Absurd? Yes, but it's the logical conclusion of their own absurd ideas.
Hate crimes laws boil down to just one thing, quelling dissent. That is to say, silencing anyone with a differing point of view, not to protect anyone, not to make society more just, but rather to eliminate freedom of speech, and with it all other freedoms we enjoy.
Labels:
Ethics,
Lies,
Life,
Marxism/Socialism,
Media Bias,
Opinion,
Philosophy
Saturday, March 14, 2009
Some Further Thoughts
Yesterday I spent quite a bit of time explaining some truth about all the media attention to the Embryonic Stem Cell Research announcement this past week. Today I want to talk about another aspect of President Obama's action.
As part of the announcement that the Federal Government will now fund Embryonic Stem Cell Research, without any regard to Ethical concerns, it was stated that President Obama is against cloning. In order to see why this is a lie, we'll have to talk a little bit about what cloning is.
There are two kinds of cloning, scientifically speaking. There is reproductive cloning, and therapeutic cloning.
First, reproductive cloning. This would involve the creation of an embryo by selectively fertilizing an egg and then placing it inside a woman (unless some way is found in the lab to grow it without a woman being involved) and allowing it to be born as a human infant. While there are some practical concerns about the viability of a person created in this manner (that is to say it's ability to survive and not mutate) but assuming those things could be overcome, one would be hard pressed to argue against this on ethical grounds. I know that's something of a shocking statement, most people believe that reproductive cloning would be terrible, and that somehow we would be playing God by doing such a thing. I can't agree with that assessment though. God created the material universe, and everything in it, including people, out of nothing. Then He gave us a command. In Genesis 1:28a God tells us, "And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth..." and while God designed a wonderful and marvelous, you might say miraculous, way for us to do this naturally, there is no prohibition against doing so by other means. To genetically engineer the clone certainly would change the discussion, but just reproductive cloning on it's own is not unethical on it's face. Oddly enough, this is the type of cloning that President Obama is opposed to.
Now, assuming just straight up cloning were perfected, what would make it unethical? Clearly treating the clone as though they had no value as a human being, and/or using them as you saw fit, against their will, would be wrong. Take for instance the idea of cloning a person, growing them into an adult and then killing them so that their organs could be used for transplant for non clones. This would be an unethical and monstrous thing to do. However, in an exaggerated way, I just described therapeutic cloning. That is where you clone an embryo and then destroy it by extracting the Stem Cells, for research, or assuming that someday they actually did find a practical use for them, which seems unlikely today, then for some therapy. That is to say, cloning a human being for the purpose of killing them for the benefit of non clones. Therapeutic cloning is at the heart of Embryonic Stem Cell Research. The research cannot be done without it.
In summary, there are two kinds of cloning, one is ethical, and one is not. President Obama is opposed to the ethical type, but supports the unethical version.
Of course, this is magnified when you consider the fact that there are literally hundreds of uses for Adult Stem Cells already in use, and Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells show even more promise, while there is not a single use of Embryonic Stem Cells yet, nor do they show any promise whatsoever. In fact, Embryonic Stem Cells cause tumors, so, rather than promising to make things better, they make things worse. So why would you support destroying Human beings, or even potential human beings, when there is both no benefit, and the benefits you are hoping for are available from another means which carries none of the moral or ethical qualms?
Doesn't seem to make much sense does it?
As part of the announcement that the Federal Government will now fund Embryonic Stem Cell Research, without any regard to Ethical concerns, it was stated that President Obama is against cloning. In order to see why this is a lie, we'll have to talk a little bit about what cloning is.
There are two kinds of cloning, scientifically speaking. There is reproductive cloning, and therapeutic cloning.
First, reproductive cloning. This would involve the creation of an embryo by selectively fertilizing an egg and then placing it inside a woman (unless some way is found in the lab to grow it without a woman being involved) and allowing it to be born as a human infant. While there are some practical concerns about the viability of a person created in this manner (that is to say it's ability to survive and not mutate) but assuming those things could be overcome, one would be hard pressed to argue against this on ethical grounds. I know that's something of a shocking statement, most people believe that reproductive cloning would be terrible, and that somehow we would be playing God by doing such a thing. I can't agree with that assessment though. God created the material universe, and everything in it, including people, out of nothing. Then He gave us a command. In Genesis 1:28a God tells us, "And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth..." and while God designed a wonderful and marvelous, you might say miraculous, way for us to do this naturally, there is no prohibition against doing so by other means. To genetically engineer the clone certainly would change the discussion, but just reproductive cloning on it's own is not unethical on it's face. Oddly enough, this is the type of cloning that President Obama is opposed to.
Now, assuming just straight up cloning were perfected, what would make it unethical? Clearly treating the clone as though they had no value as a human being, and/or using them as you saw fit, against their will, would be wrong. Take for instance the idea of cloning a person, growing them into an adult and then killing them so that their organs could be used for transplant for non clones. This would be an unethical and monstrous thing to do. However, in an exaggerated way, I just described therapeutic cloning. That is where you clone an embryo and then destroy it by extracting the Stem Cells, for research, or assuming that someday they actually did find a practical use for them, which seems unlikely today, then for some therapy. That is to say, cloning a human being for the purpose of killing them for the benefit of non clones. Therapeutic cloning is at the heart of Embryonic Stem Cell Research. The research cannot be done without it.
In summary, there are two kinds of cloning, one is ethical, and one is not. President Obama is opposed to the ethical type, but supports the unethical version.
Of course, this is magnified when you consider the fact that there are literally hundreds of uses for Adult Stem Cells already in use, and Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells show even more promise, while there is not a single use of Embryonic Stem Cells yet, nor do they show any promise whatsoever. In fact, Embryonic Stem Cells cause tumors, so, rather than promising to make things better, they make things worse. So why would you support destroying Human beings, or even potential human beings, when there is both no benefit, and the benefits you are hoping for are available from another means which carries none of the moral or ethical qualms?
Doesn't seem to make much sense does it?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)